A Case for the Existence of God

Inside a small office in Idaho, two single fathers meet to discuss the mortgage on a modest piece of land. What begins as a routine conversation between a loan officer and his client slowly unfolds into something far more profound.

Over a series of quiet encounters, Keith and Ryan share stories of fatherhood, loss, hope, and the fragile ways we try to build a life for ourselves and the people we love. As their conversations deepen, an unlikely friendship begins to form — one that gently asks what it means to believe in goodness, connection, and the possibility of grace in an uncertain world.

With remarkable tenderness and subtle humor, Pulitzer Prize finalist Samuel D. Hunter (The Whale) crafts a deeply moving portrait of two ordinary men searching for stability, meaning, and a place to belong.

Intimate, compassionate, and quietly powerful, “A Case for the Existence of God” reminds us that sometimes the most extraordinary revelations emerge from the most ordinary conversations.

New Hampshire Premiere

***

“Quietly shattering… one of the most moving plays of the decade.”
— The New York Times

“A profound and beautifully written meditation on faith, friendship, and fatherhood.”
— New York Stage Review

“Samuel D. Hunter has written a small miracle of a play.”
— The Daily Beast

Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays at 7 PM

Saturdays and Sundays at 2 PM

Duration: check later!

Curious about the process?

The first Sunday matinee show will be followed by an optional talkback with the director and cast.

General Admission: $33

Seniors (65+) / Students / Veterans / First Responders: $31

Enquire about group discounts at the Box Office.

Seating is unassigned. Doors open 30 minutes before showtime.

The show will begin on time. Due to the intimate nature of our space, late seating is not permitted.